8 Best Longhorn Cheese Substitute

Longhorn Cheese Substitute

The best Longhorn cheese substitute is plain Colby, which is the exact same cheese pressed into a different shape, giving you identical flavor, texture, and melt with no compromise. I had never actually thought about what Longhorn cheese was until I found myself standing in a grocery store looking for it and realizing I had

8 Best Sulguni Cheese Substitutes

Sulgini cheese substitutes

The best Sulguni cheese substitute is low-moisture mozzarella mixed with a small amount of feta, which recreates Suluguni’s melt, stretch, and tangy-salty flavor better than any single cheese on its own. I have to be upfront about something: the original version of this article said Sulguni comes from Italy. That is completely wrong, and I

9 Best Teleme Cheese Substitutes

teleme cheese substitutes

The best Teleme cheese substitutes is Brie, which shares the same soft, buttery, melt-in-your-mouth texture and mild, lightly tangy flavor that makes Teleme so special on pizza, polenta, and cheese boards. I spent years thinking Teleme cheese was just some obscure California thing until I finally tried it melted over polenta at a San Francisco

10 Best Stilton Cheese Substitutes

Stilton Cheese Substitutes

The best Stilton cheese substitute is Gorgonzola Piccante, which matches Stilton’s crumbly texture and bold blue character closely enough to work in every dish that calls for it. I remember the first time a recipe called for Stilton and I stood in the cheese aisle completely lost. The store had about six varieties of cheddar

6 Best Castelmagno Cheese Substitute

Castelmagno Cheese Substitute

The best Castelmagno cheese substitute is Gorgonzola Dolce, which replicates the creamy, mildly tangy character and melts beautifully into pasta sauces and risotto. Castelmagno is one of those cheeses that sounds like it should be easy to find and then absolutely isn’t. It comes from a tiny pocket of Piedmont in northern Italy, and fewer

10 Best Dubliner Cheese Substitutes

Best Dubliner Cheese Substitutes - assorted cheese alternatives

The best Dubliner cheese substitutes are aged sharp cheddar, a blend of sharp cheddar and Parmigiano-Reggiano, Gruyere, aged Gouda, Parmigiano-Reggiano, Bellavitano Gold, Red Leicester, cashew cheese, soy-based cheese, and nutritional yeast. I ran out of Kerrygold Dubliner mid-recipe once and spent 10 minutes panicking in front of my fridge. It has such a specific flavor

10 Best Caerphilly Cheese Substitutes

Caerphilly Cheese Substitutes

The best Caerphilly cheese substitutes are Cheddar cheese, Wensleydale cheese, Feta Cheese, Monterey Jack Cheese, Havarti Cheese, Gouda Cheese, Colby Cheese, Lancashire Cheese, Muenster Cheese, and Fontina Cheese. A friend of mine contacted me about a recipe she wanted to make that needed Caerphilly Cheese, but she couldn’t get her hands on any. She was

9 Best Locatelli Cheese Substitute

Locatelli Cheese Substitute

The Best Locatelli Cheese Substitutes are Parmesan Cheese, Grana Padano Cheese, Asiago Cheese, Spanish Manchego Cheese, Piave Cheese, Nutritional Yeast, Iberico Cheese, Ossau Iraty Cheese, and Pecorino Romano Cheese. When I wanted to try out a new pasta recipe that required Locatelli cheese, I faced a problem. I couldn’t find the cheese in my local