10 Best Tilsit Cheese Substitute

This post contains affiliate links. This means if you make a purchase using these links, we may receive a commission at no extra charge to you. Thank you for supporting Cyanne Eats!

Are you a cheese lover looking for a new flavor to add to your favorite dishes? Look no further than Tilsit Cheese, a delicious and versatile cheese that originated in East Prussia and has become popular around the world. But, if you’re having issues finding Tilsit Cheese in your local grocery store, don’t worry. There are several other kinds of cheese that can be a tasty substitute.

One of the best Tilsit Cheese substitute is Havarti, a semi-soft cheese that has a similar mild, buttery flavor and creamy texture. Havarti is a Danish cheese that is easy to find in most grocery stores. You can use it when preparing different meals like sandwiches, wraps, pasta, and omelets. Other good substitutes for Tilsit Cheese include Gouda, Edam, and Swiss cheese, which all have a mild flavor and firm texture that makes them a great addition to many different recipes. So whether you’re cooking up a storm in the kitchen or just looking for a delicious snack, don’t be afraid to experiment with different types of cheese and find the perfect Tilsit Cheese substitute.

What is Tilsit Cheese?

Tilsit Cheese is a semi-hard cheese that originated in Tilsit, a town in East Prussia (now known as Sovetsk in Russia). It is made from cow’s milk and has a pale yellow color, firm texture, and a tangy, slightly sour flavor.

During the production of Tilsit Cheese, the milk is first curdled with rennet, which is an enzyme that helps the milk solids separate from the liquid. The curds are then cut into small pieces and pressed to remove excess whey. Afterward, the cheese is shaped into a wheel and allowed to age for several weeks, during which it develops a rind and a distinct flavor.

Tilsit Cheese is often compared to other German and Dutch cheeses, such as Gouda and Edam, because of its texture and flavor. You can use it in different dishes, like pizzas and casseroles, or eat it alone as an appetizer or a snack.

There are different types of Tilsit Cheese, including smoked Tilsit and Tilsit with caraway seeds. These variations have their own unique flavors and aromas.

Tilsit Cheese is popular in Europe and is exported to other parts of the world for people to enjoy.

Substitutes For Tilsit Cheese

1. Gouda Cheese

Gouda Cheese

Gouda Cheese is a semi-hard cheese originating from the Netherlands. It is produced from cow’s milk. It is a great substitute for Tilsit Cheese, thanks to its mild, slightly sweet flavor and firm, elastic texture.

Like Tilsit Cheese, Gouda Cheese is a versatile cheese as you can use in different meals. It can be melted over pasta, used in sandwiches, or served on a cheese platter with fruits and crackers. Gouda Cheese comes in different varieties, like smoked Gouda, which adds a smoky flavor to dishes, and then aged Gouda, which has a nuttier flavor and a crumbly texture.

2. Edam Cheese

Edam Cheese

When it comes to finding a substitute for Tilsit Cheese, Edam Cheese is a great option. This semi-hard cheese originated in the Netherlands and is made from cow’s milk. It has a mild, nutty flavor and a firm, smooth texture that makes it a versatile cheese for various dishes.

Edam Cheese can be used in many ways. It can be melted over pasta, used in sandwiches, or served on a cheese platter with fruits and crackers. It is also often used as a snacking cheese, thanks to its convenient size and easy-to-eat shape. Edam Cheese is widely available in most grocery stores, making it a convenient choice for those who cannot find Tilsit Cheese in their area.

3. Havarti Cheese

Havarti Cheese

If you’re looking for a substitute for Tilsit Cheese that has a similar creamy texture and mild flavor, look no further than Havarti Cheese. This semi-soft cheese is a Danish specialty made from cow’s milk and has a buttery, nutty taste with a hint of sweetness.

Havarti Cheese is a versatile cheese that can be used in many different ways, just like Tilsit Cheese. It’s a great cheese to use for melting over pasta, vegetables, or potatoes, and it makes an excellent addition to sandwiches or cheese platters. Havarti Cheese can also be enjoyed on its own as a snacking cheese or paired with fruits and crackers for a light snack.

4. Fontina Cheese

Fontina Cheese

If you’re looking for a delicious substitute for Tilsit Cheese, I highly recommend trying Fontina Cheese. This Italian cheese has a smooth and creamy texture with a slightly nutty flavor that’s similar to Tilsit Cheese, making it a great choice for a variety of dishes.

One of the best things about Fontina Cheese is its versatility. It’s perfect for melting over pasta dishes, adding to sandwiches, or using in cheese platters. It’s also a great snacking cheese that pairs well with crackers and fruit.

Another great thing about Fontina Cheese is how easy it is to find. Most grocery stores carry it and it’s often less expensive than Tilsit Cheese, so it’s a budget-friendly option for those who want to switch up their cheese game. So why not give Fontina Cheese a try? It’s sure to become a new favorite in your kitchen!

5. Colby Cheese

Colby Cheese

Colby Cheese is a great substitute for Tilsit Cheese due to its similar mild and slightly tangy flavor profile. This American cheese is famous for its smooth and creamy texture, with a slightly sweet and nutty taste. Colby Cheese also has a firm texture that makes it easy to slice and melt, making it perfect for sandwiches, burgers, and other dishes where you want a cheese that will hold its shape.

6. Monterey Jack Cheese

Monterey Jack Cheese

Monterey Jack Cheese is a popular cheese in the United States, and it can be a great substitute for Tilsit Cheese. This cheese has a mild and slightly sweet flavor profile with a creamy texture, making it a great melting cheese. Monterey Jack Cheese is also known for its smooth buttery taste, making it perfect for adding flavor to various dishes.

In terms of texture, Monterey Jack Cheese is semi-soft and has a creamy, ivory color. It’s typically aged for only a few months, which gives it a mild taste compared to other cheeses that are aged for longer periods. The texture is smooth and elastic, making it perfect for melting on dishes like pizza, burgers, and nachos.

Overall, Monterey Jack Cheese is a versatile cheese that can be used in many of the same ways as Tilsit Cheese. It’s great in sandwiches, burgers, and cheese platters, and it can be used as a substitute in recipes that call for Tilsit Cheese. Give it a try and see how it works in your favorite recipes!

7. Brick Cheese

Brick Cheese

If you’re looking for a substitute for Tilsit Cheese that has a similar flavor profile, you might want to consider Brick Cheese. This Wisconsin cheese has a mild, nutty flavor with a slightly tangy finish that’s similar to Tilsit Cheese. It also has a smooth texture that makes it a great melting cheese for dishes like grilled cheese sandwiches or pizza.

One of the unique things about Brick Cheese is its history. It was first made by German immigrants in Wisconsin in the 1800s, so it has a similar origin story to Tilsit Cheese. Over time, it became a staple in American cuisine and is now widely available in most grocery stores.

Brick Cheese is a great substitute for Tilsit Cheese in dishes like sandwiches, burgers, or cheese platters. It pairs well with fruits like apples or pears and goes great with a variety of crackers. If you’re looking for a cheese with a similar flavor profile to Tilsit Cheese, give Brick Cheese a try!

8. Cheddar Cheese

Cheddar Cheese

Cheddar Cheese is a widely popular cheese in the United States and can be a great alternative to Tilsit Cheese. This semi-hard cheese boasts a sharper and more complex flavor profile than Tilsit, with a tangy and slightly nutty taste. Cheddar cheese’s flavor varies from mild to sharp. But, it all depends on how long it has been aged, making it a versatile ingredient in several dishes.

Cheddar cheese has a crumbly and smooth texture. They usually let it age for several months, leading to a firmer texture and a more robust flavor. It comes in different colors, ranging from white to yellow and even orange, depending on the food coloring. Some cheddar cheeses also feature a unique taste that comes from being aged in caves or infused with herbs or spices.

9. Muenster Cheese

Muenster Cheese

Muenster Cheese is a semi-soft cheese that can be an excellent substitute for Tilsit Cheese. It originated in France. But, presently Muenster Cheese is commonly produced in the United States. Muenster has a mild and slightly tangy flavor profile that is similar to Tilsit, with a creamy and buttery taste. It is also slightly salty, which adds to its flavor complexity.

Muenster Cheese has a pale yellow interior with an orange rind that is formed from being coated in a mixture of annatto and other natural ingredients. The rind is edible and adds a slightly earthy and nutty flavor to the cheese. Muenster has a smooth and supple texture that melts easily. This makes it a perfect cheese for grilled sandwiches, macaroni and cheese, and other melted cheese dishes.

10. Swiss Cheese

Swiss Cheese

Swiss Cheese is a great replacement for Tilsit Cheese as it has a similar flavor. Also, it’s is a versatile cheese you can use in various dishes. This cheese originated in Switzerland. It is famous for its distinct holes, also known as “eyes.” The flavor of Swiss Cheese is mild and nutty, and it has a slightly sweet taste that is similar to Tilsit. The texture of Swiss Cheese is firm and elastic, with a smooth mouthfeel.

Swiss Cheese has a pale yellow interior and a rind that is often brushed with brine to enhance its flavor. Swiss Cheese’s flavor varies based on the aging process, with younger cheeses having a milder taste and aged cheeses having a more complex flavor. Swiss Cheese pairs well with various foods, like sandwiches, salads, and baked dishes. It can also be melted easily, making it a great choice for meals like fondue and quiches. While Swiss Cheese is not an exact match for Tilsit Cheese, it is a fantastic substitute with a mild and nutty flavor that can enhance the taste of many recipes.


There are several delicious cheese alternatives to Tilsit cheese that can be used in a variety of dishes. From the nutty and creamy Havarti to the mild and buttery Colby, each cheese has its own unique flavor profile that can add depth and richness to any recipe. Whether you’re looking for a cheese to snack on, melt over pasta or potatoes, or add to a cheese platter, there is a perfect substitute for Tilsit cheese out there. Don’t be afraid to experiment with different cheeses and find your own favorite substitute. The world of cheese is huge and tasty, and there’s always something new to discover.

About Cynthia

Cynthia Odenu-Odenu is the founder of Cyanne Eats. She is an avid baker and cook of delicious delicacies. She uses this blog to share her love for different cuisines.

Learn More

Leave a Reply