10 Best Longhorn Cheese Substitute

This post contains affiliate links. This means if you make a purchase using these links, we may receive a commission at no extra charge to you. Thank you for supporting Cyanne Eats!

The Best Longhorn Cheese Substitutes are Cheddar Cheese, Mozzarella Cheese, Tillamook Cheese, Colby Cheese, Gruyere Cheese, Edam Cheese, Double Gloucester Cheese, Cantal Cheese, Brick Cheese, and Gouda Cheese.

When my friend and I decided to whip up a recipe that called for Longhorn Cheese, we hit a roadblock as it was nowhere to be found. Undeterred, I turned to a Longhorn Cheese substitute using a mix of sharp cheddar and Colby cheeses. The result surprised us with its rich flavor and melt-in-your-mouth texture, proving that improvisation can lead to delightful discoveries.

In this article, you’ll be learning some substitutes for Longhorn cheese.

Best Longhorn Cheese Substitute

1. Cheddar Cheese

Cheddar Cheese - Longhorn Cheese Alternative

If you’re in need of a substitute for Longhorn Cheese, Cheddar Cheese is an excellent choice. Longhorn cheese is essentially a slightly processed American Cheddar, so opting for mild or young Cheddar will provide the right texture and flavors.

You can seamlessly replace Longhorn with an equal amount of Cheddar in any recipe. Cheddar offers a comparable easily meltable texture and shares a similar taste profile, making it a versatile and fitting alternative for various culinary applications.

2. Mozzarella Cheese

Mozarrella cheese - Longhorn Chheese Replacement

When searching for a melty and flavorful cheese alternative to Longhorn, Mozzarella is an excellent choice. Mozzarella is known for its mild flavor and stretchy and chewy texture, making it a great addition to dishes like pasta, mac and cheese, baked, or grilled cheese. It’s widely available in stores, adding to its convenience.

Substituting Longhorn cheese with an equal measure of Mozzarella (1:1 ratio) is viable, although you can anticipate some flavor differences in the final recipe. Nonetheless, Mozzarella provides a satisfying cheesy factor to various dishes.

3. Tillamook Cheese

Tillamook Cheese is an excellent substitute for Longhorn Cheese, known for its soft and melty cheddar that is native to America and readily available. This mild-flavored cheese boasts a smooth and creamy texture, making it ideal for applications like grilled cheese sandwiches or as an everyday cheese.

Being a creamier version of cheddar, Tillamook can seamlessly replace Longhorn cheese in recipes like pasta, grilled cheese, mac and cheese, and more. Simply use equal portions of Tillamook cheese in place of Longhorn to maintain a rich and satisfying texture in your favorite dishes.

4. Colby Cheese

Colby Cheese serves as an excellent replacement for Longhorn Cheese due to its similarities to Cheddar and its mild, creamy, or buttery taste, akin to Longhorn cheese. Colby melts wonderfully, making it a versatile option for a variety of recipes. Its availability adds to its convenience, making it easy to find in stores. Given the similar textures and flavor profiles, you can seamlessly replace Longhorn cheese with a 1:1 ratio of Colby cheese in any recipe, ensuring a consistent and satisfying result in your dishes.

5. Gruyere Cheese

Gruyere Cheese - Longhorn Cheese Substitute

Gruyere Cheese is an excellent Longhorn Cheese substitute, offering a slightly different flavor profile with earthy and nutty notes while maintaining the desirable textural goodness of being melty and creamy. Whether in cheesy grilled sandwiches, mac and cheese, or bakes, Gruyere provides a delicious alternative.

You can seamlessly replace Longhorn cheese with the same ratio of Gruyere in almost any recipe. While there might be subtle flavor differences, the resulting dish will be equally delightful, showcasing the unique qualities of Gruyere in your favorite dishes.

6. Edam Cheese 

Edam Cheese  - Substitute for Longhorn Cheese

Edam Cheese is an excellent alternative to Longhorn Cheese, especially for those seeking a lower-fat option while still enjoying the flavors and textural goodness similar to Longhorn. Edam is soft and melty, making it an ideal choice for pasta, bakes, casseroles, and even pairing well with fruits. Given its resemblance to Gouda cheese in terms of texture and flavor, and considering that Gouda can be substituted in equal measures, you can seamlessly use a 1:1 ratio of Edam cheese to Longhorn cheese when substituting. This ensures your recipes maintain their intended taste and texture while providing a lower-fat alternative.

7. Double Gloucester Cheese 

Double Gloucester cheese - Longhorn Cheese Substitute

Double Gloucester Cheese is a fantastic Longhorn Cheese alternative, offering a British alternative for various recipes. With its rich and buttery taste, it shares a texture quite similar to Longhorn. Double Gloucester melts wonderfully, making it an excellent choice for grilling or grating over dishes. Given its similarities to cheddar cheese, you can easily use equal measures of Double Gloucester to substitute Longhorn in most recipes, ensuring a delicious and satisfying result while adding a British twist to your culinary creations.

8. Cantal Cheese

Cantal Cheese serves as an excellent Longhorn Cheese replacement, especially if you’re looking for a flavor reminiscent of Cheddar or Longhorn. The less mature or mild Cantal closely resembles Longhorn in taste, while aging imparts spicier and crumblier characteristics. Cantal is an ideal substitute in baking recipes such as quiche or tart. You can seamlessly replace Longhorn cheese in most recipes in equal measure when using mild Cantal cheese. It’s important to note that as Cantal ages, the flavor profile changes, which may impact the overall results of the recipe, providing versatility for different culinary preferences.

9. Brick Cheese

Brick Cheese is an excellent Longhorn Cheese substitute, offering a milky and mild flavor, especially in its less mature state. Like cheddar, it is an ideal replacement for Longhorn, particularly in sandwiches and mac and cheese recipes where a melty and mild cheese is desired to enhance flavors. Although slightly fattier than Longhorn or cheddar cheese, Brick cheese can be used in equal measures to substitute Longhorn cheese in most recipes, ensuring a smooth transition without compromising your dishes’ intended taste and texture.

10. Gouda Cheese

Gouda Cheese - Longhorn Cheese Substitutes

Young or mild Gouda proves to be an excellent substitute for Longhorn Cheese in various recipes. With its mild and milky flavor and subtle notes of sweetness, Gouda works seamlessly in dishes ranging from sandwiches to soups and potato bakes. Its ability to melt well makes it an ideal alternative, especially in recipes where Longhorn cheese is called for. You can easily use Gouda in equal measures to replace Longhorn cheese in any recipe, and it particularly excels as a substitute in grilled cheese sandwiches, providing a delicious twist to these classic favorites.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Colby Cheese The Same As Longhorn Cheese? 

No, Colby cheese is not the same as Longhorn cheese. Colby and Longhorn are distinct types of cheese. Colby is a semi-hard cheese with a mild flavor and smooth texture, while Longhorn cheese is essentially a version of Colby that is shaped into long, cylindrical logs. The differences lie in texture, flavor, and shape, making them distinct varieties within the category of American cheeses.

What Is Equivalent to Longhorn Cheese?

An equivalent to Longhorn cheese can be Colby cheese, as Longhorn cheese is essentially a version of Colby that is traditionally shaped into long, cylindrical logs. Colby cheese shares similar characteristics with Longhorn, including a mild flavor and a semi-soft to semi-hard texture. Therefore, if Longhorn cheese is unavailable, Colby cheese can be a suitable substitute, offering a comparable taste and texture for various culinary applications.

Is Longhorn Cheese the Same as Mild Cheddar?

No, Longhorn cheese is not the same as Mild Cheddar. While both are American cheese types, they have flavor and texture differences. Longhorn cheese is a variation of Colby cheese, known for its mild taste and elastic texture. Mild Cheddar, on the other hand, is a type of Cheddar cheese with a slightly sharper flavor and a firmer texture than Colby or Longhorn. The distinctions between the two lie in the production process and the aging period, resulting in variations in taste and consistency.

Is Longhorn Cheese a Hard Cheese?

No, Longhorn cheese is not a hard cheese. Longhorn cheese is a type of American cheese derived from Colby cheese, characterized by its mild flavor and semi-hard to semi-soft texture. It does not undergo the same level of aging or fermentation as hard cheeses, such as aged Cheddar or Parmesan. The texture of Longhorn cheese tends to be more elastic and pliable, distinguishing it from the firmness associated with hard cheeses.

What Makes Longhorn Cheese Different?

Longhorn cheese is distinctive for its mild flavor and semi-soft-to-semi-hard texture. It is a variation of Colby cheese, characterized by its elastic and pliable consistency. The unique feature of Longhorn cheese is its traditional shaping into long, cylindrical logs, which gives it its name. This type of American cheese is recognized for its versatility, being suitable for melting in various dishes or enjoyed on its own. The combination of its mild taste, texture, and characteristic shape sets Longhorn cheese apart from other varieties within the American cheese category.

What Is the Difference Between Longhorn Cheddar and Regular Cheddar?

The main difference between Longhorn Cheddar and regular Cheddar lies in their texture and shape. Longhorn Cheddar is a variation of Colby cheese, known for its mild flavor and semi-soft to semi-hard texture. It is typically shaped into long, cylindrical logs, giving it the “Longhorn” name. On the other hand, regular Cheddar is a distinct type of cheese known for its sharper flavor and firm texture. While both share the Cheddar category, Longhorn Cheddar’s unique characteristics include its mild taste, semi-soft texture, and elongated shape, setting it apart from the more traditional Cheddar cheese.

What Is Longhorn Cheese Used For?

Longhorn cheese is versatile and can be used in various culinary applications. Its mild and creamy flavor and semi-soft texture make it suitable for a range of uses. It is commonly used in sandwiches, burgers, and wraps, where its melting qualities enhance the overall taste. Longhorn cheese can also be melted into sauces, used in casseroles, or enjoyed on its own as a snack or part of a cheese platter. Its versatility in both flavor and texture makes Longhorn cheese a popular choice for everyday cooking and entertaining.

What Does Longhorn Cheddar Taste Like?

Longhorn Cheddar has a mild and slightly tangy flavor with a creamy texture. It combines the characteristics of Longhorn cheese, a variation of Colby, with the sharper and more pronounced taste commonly associated with Cheddar. The result is a cheese that is not overly intense but still has a noticeable savory profile. The flavor can vary depending on factors like the aging process and production methods, but generally, Longhorn Cheddar is appreciated for its balanced taste that falls between the mildness of Colby and the sharper notes of traditional Cheddar.

Is There a Longhorn Cheddar Cheese?

No, there is no specific Longhorn Cheddar cheese. Longhorn cheese is a type of American cheese that is a variation of Colby, known for its mild flavor and semi-soft texture. On the other hand, Cheddar cheese is a distinct type of cheese with its own characteristics, including a sharper flavor and a firmer texture. While both Longhorn and Cheddar are types of American cheeses, they are separate varieties with unique qualities, and there isn’t a specific cheese that combines the features of both as “Longhorn Cheddar.”


I hope you found every tip I shared in this article on the best Longhorn cheese substitute useful.

You can share this with your friends and family.

About Cynthia

Cynthia Odenu-Odenu is the founder of Cyanne Eats. She is an avid baker and cook of delicious delicacies. She uses this blog to share her love for different cuisines.

Learn More

Leave a Reply