Costco’s Thanksgiving Haul: What’s Actually Worth Buying This Year

Costco’s best Thanksgiving dinner buys this year are the Kirkland Signature turkey dinner kit for a stress-free main, the loaded mashed potatoes for the single best pre-made side, and the $5.99 pumpkin pie for dessert, while the full $199.99 complete dinner package is worth it only if you’re feeding a crowd and truly don’t want to cook.

I go into Costco every October telling myself I’m just going to grab cranberry sauce and get out. I never do. By the time I’ve walked the seasonal aisle twice, I’ve got a cart full of pie, a five-pound tub of mashed potatoes, and a turkey breast I didn’t plan on buying.

That’s kind of the whole Costco Thanksgiving experience. It’s not really shopping, it’s grazing through a buffet of shortcuts and deciding which ones earn a spot at your table.

I’ve bought most of the seasonal lineup at this point, some years for my own dinner and some years just to see what all the fuss was about. Below is how I’d spend my money this year, item by item, including where I think Costco is genuinely overselling itself.

Key takeaways

• The Kirkland Signature turkey dinner kit at $3.99 a pound is the best value on the whole seasonal table, and it feeds a group without asking you to cook a raw bird.
• Loaded mashed potatoes are the one pre-made side I’d never skip. Three cheeses, real bacon, and they hold up in the oven without going gluey.
• The $5.99 pumpkin pie is nearly four pounds of pie and honestly better than what most people bake at home.
• The $199.99 complete dinner package works out to about $25 a person, which beats a restaurant, but it’s a lot of food for a small household.
• Skip the homemade dinner roll ambitions. Kirkland’s butter rolls are under $8 for thirty and nobody will know the difference.

The turkey: buy the kit, not just the bird

Costco sells turkey about six different ways in November, and it gets confusing fast. This is how I sort through it every year.

Whole fresh or frozen turkey. This is the classic move, and some years Costco still runs a turkey close to a dollar a pound if you buy early enough. A 14-pound bird at that price runs you under $15 and easily feeds ten to twelve people. The catch is you’re doing all the cooking yourself, brining included if you want it juicy.

Kirkland Signature Turkey Dinner Kit with Stuffing and Gravy. This is the one that went a little viral, and I get why. It’s priced per pound around $3.99, comes with stuffing and gravy built in, and a typical kit feeds a small gathering for well under $25 total. I tried this one last year expecting it to taste like a hotel banquet, and the gravy actually had some depth to it.

Whole smoked turkey. Fully cooked, sold by the pound, and it’s the move if your oven is already full of side dishes and you need one less thing to babysit. I wouldn’t call it a traditional Thanksgiving centerpiece, but as a backup or a Friendsgiving option it earns its price.

Sliced or oven-roasted turkey breast. Good for a small household or if you’re hosting a crowd that mostly wants sandwiches later. Not worth it if you actually want the whole roasted-bird moment at the table.

My honest take: unless you specifically love the ritual of roasting your own turkey, the dinner kit beats a plain whole bird on value once you factor in how much a bag of stuffing mix and a jar of gravy would cost you separately.

Costco Thanksgiving sides worth your cart space

This is where Costco actually earns its reputation, and it’s the section people search for every year once they’ve settled the turkey question.

Side	Price	Worth it?
Loaded mashed potatoes (three cheese, bacon)	About $3.49/lb, roughly $12 per container	Yes, buy every time
Mac and cheese	Around $11	Yes, crowd-pleaser, kids love it
Lobster mac and cheese	About $6.99/lb, roughly $30 a tray	Only for a smaller, splurgier table
Cornbread or traditional stuffing	Varies by region	Good backup if you’re not doing the turkey kit
Green bean casserole	Sold seasonally, moderate price	Fine, not exciting
Ocean Spray cranberry sauce, 6-pack	About $10.99	Skip unless you’re hosting multiple gatherings
Crispy fried onions, 1.5 lb bag	Budget-friendly	Yes, and buy it early, it sells out

The loaded mashed potatoes are the one item I will defend to anyone. Three cheeses, real bacon crumbles, butter and sour cream mixed through, and you just bake it for about 45 minutes at 350. I’ve made mashed potatoes from scratch plenty of times and this version genuinely holds its own next to homemade, texture and all.

The lobster mac and cheese is a fun splurge but I wouldn’t build a whole dinner around it. It’s rich in a way that works better as a side for six people than a main event for twelve.

Skip the canned cranberry sauce from Costco specifically. It comes in a six-pack, which is way more than most households need for one dinner, and a single can from the regular grocery aisle does the exact same job for less.

Pies and dessert: the pumpkin pie is the real headline

Costco’s seasonal pie lineup shows up in three flavors, and the price gap between them tells you a lot about where to spend.

• Pumpkin pie, $5.99. Nearly four pounds of pie for under six dollars. This is the one I always end up buying two of, one for the actual holiday and one because it never survives past the first slice.
• Apple pie, $12.99. A big lattice-top pie with real cinnamon-forward filling. Good, but not dramatically better than a decent grocery store apple pie for double the price of the pumpkin.
• Pecan pie, $16.99. This one’s genuinely impressive, glossy and rich with a caramel filling that tastes closer to a bakery pie than a warehouse one. Worth it if pecan pie is a tradition in your house, skip it if nobody at your table actually eats the whole slice.

If I had to pick one dessert and walk away, it’s the pumpkin pie every single time. The value on that thing is almost silly.

Rolls, sides you can skip, and the small stuff

Kirkland Signature Butter Dinner Rolls run under $8 for thirty rolls, and they’re soft enough that I’ve stopped feeling any guilt about not baking my own. I used to insist on homemade rolls every year, mostly out of stubbornness, and eventually admitted the store version freed up an entire afternoon I used to spend baking instead of actually enjoying the day.

King’s Hawaiian sweet rolls are also stocked around the holidays if your table leans a little sweeter than a plain butter roll. Either one is a safe buy.

A few smaller items worth grabbing while you’re there: the organic chicken stock multi-pack is genuinely useful for gravy backup, and the fried onions for topping the green bean casserole tend to disappear off shelves close to the holiday, so I’d grab those earlier rather than later.

The complete Thanksgiving dinner package: who it’s actually for

Costco also sells a full pre-order dinner package, and this is the one people ask me about most. It runs $199.99, feeds around eight people, and includes a turkey breast, mashed potatoes, gravy, mac and cheese, corn, green beans, cranberry relish, dinner rolls, and two pies.

Do the math and that’s roughly $25 per person, which genuinely beats most restaurant Thanksgiving prices in most cities. For a big gathering where you want zero cooking stress, it’s a solid deal.

Where I go back and forth on this one is smaller households. If you’re feeding four people, you’re paying for a lot of food you’ll be eating as leftovers for a week straight, which isn’t necessarily bad, just worth knowing going in. I’d rather build my own smaller version from the individual items above if my table is under six people.

What I’d actually put in my cart this year

If I’m hosting a table of eight or more and want minimal effort, I’m getting the turkey dinner kit, the loaded mashed potatoes, the pumpkin pie, and the butter rolls, and calling it done. That combination alone comes in well under what the full package costs and gives me more control over exactly how much of each thing I actually need.

If I’m hosting a smaller table, I skip the turkey kit’s built-in sides, buy a smaller whole turkey or a turkey breast instead, and pick two sides instead of stocking up on everything.

Either way, I’m buying the pumpkin pie. That one’s not optional.

If you’re also comparing prices across other discount grocers this season, it’s worth checking how Aldi and Walmart stack up on the individual ingredients, since some Thanksgiving basics are actually cheaper outside the warehouse club model.

Frequently asked questions